PJM’s December 2025 Capacity Auction Left a 6,600 MW Gap: What NJ Homeowners Need to Know

Illustration for the article PJM’s December 2025 Capacity Auction Left a 6,600 MW Gap: What NJ Homeowners Need to Know

Summary

In December 2025, PJM Interconnection — the grid operator that keeps the lights on for more than 67 million people across 13 states, including New Jersey — held its 2027/2028 Base Residual Auction. The result was historic in the worst way: the auction cleared at the FERC-approved price cap of $333.44 per megawatt-day and still fell 6,623 MW short of PJM’s own reliability requirement — the first time in the capacity market’s 18-year history that it had missed its target.

For a Monmouth County homeowner, those numbers translate directly into your electric bill. New Jersey utilities buy power through PJM’s annual Basic Generation Service (BGS) auction each February, and the wholesale capacity price set in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania flows through to what you pay JCP&L or PSE&G every month starting June 1. The 2025 BGS auction — driven largely by the prior capacity price spike — already pushed JCP&L bills up 20.2% and PSE&G bills up 17.24%. The December 2025 auction’s $333.44 cap price is the next step in that staircase, with its costs scheduled to begin flowing into bills on June 1, 2027.

The more troubling finding is structural. PJM procured less capacity than required to meet its one-event-in-10-years reliability standard, at a reserve margin of just 14.8% against a target closer to 20%. Supply is not growing fast enough to meet demand driven largely by data centers, and the price signal — even at the FERC cap — has not been enough to bring new generation online. That gap is not a one-time blip; it reflects years of permitting delays, infrastructure constraints, and retirement of older dispatchable plants.

For a New Jersey homeowner who wants to do something about grid volatility rather than simply absorb the next rate increase, a natural-gas or propane standby generator is one of the most practical answers. It does not reduce your electric bill, but it insulates your household from the real-world consequence of a tighter, more stressed grid: outages. Green Sun Energy Services installs Generac standby generators throughout Monmouth County and can help you assess which system fits your home.

What exactly is PJM's capacity auction, and why should a New Jersey homeowner care?

PJM Interconnection is the regional transmission organization that operates the electricity grid across 13 states and the District of Columbia, including all of New Jersey. It is the world’s largest electric generation capacity market, and every power plant that wants to sell electricity in this region participates in it.

Once a year, PJM runs what it calls a Base Residual Auction (BRA). The auction does not buy electricity itself — it buys a promise. Power plant owners bid to guarantee they will be available to generate electricity during a specific future 12-month period called the “delivery year,” which runs from June 1 through May 31. These payments are built into PJM customers’ electricity bills as the capacity price, and they are priced roughly three years in advance of when the lights actually need to stay on.

For New Jersey households, the connection is direct. Every June, the generation price on a New Jersey bill resets based on the state’s annual BGS auction, and a major part of that price comes from PJM’s capacity market — a charge everyone pays to ensure that enough power plants are available during peak hours. The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities (NJBPU) certified the 2026 BGS auction results on February 12, 2026, with the rates flowing through to customer bills on June 1, 2026. The December 2025 auction’s price, meanwhile, is already locked in and queued for June 1, 2027.

The practical implication: a wholesale auction held in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, years before the electricity is generated, determines a meaningful slice of what you pay on your monthly utility bill in Monmouth County. That is not a flaw in the system — it is how grid reliability is designed to be funded. The flaw, as the December 2025 auction made clear, is that the system is not generating enough supply to meet rising demand.

What happened at the December 2025 PJM capacity auction?

On December 17, 2025, PJM announced the results of its 2027/2028 Base Residual Auction. The auction secured 134,479 MW of unforced capacity generation and demand response to meet projected electricity needs for more than 67 million people. The price landed at the ceiling: the FERC-approved cap of $333.44 per megawatt-day, a slight increase of 1.3% from the previous auction.

To put that number in historical context: just two auction cycles earlier, the 2024/2025 delivery-year auction cleared at $28.92 per megawatt-day. The December 2025 price represents an increase of more than 1,050% in roughly four years. The clearing price landed at the FERC-approved cap for the second consecutive year, with prices pinned at the ceiling.

But the price was not the most consequential part of the announcement. Even when combined with resources procured through Fixed Resource Requirement programs, the auction fell short of PJM’s reliability requirement by 6,623 MW, translating to a reserve margin of 14.8% versus a target closer to 20%. It was the first time the auction had not met the reliability requirement since the capacity market was created in 2007.

The auction cleared only 774 MW of new generation and power plant uprates — a number that illustrates the core problem: even at historically high prices, very little new supply showed up. “It’s unsurprising that almost no new capacity showed up because projects in PJM are still struggling to get built,” said Julia Hoos, head of USA East at Aurora Energy Research.

Why are PJM capacity prices rising — and why can't the market fix itself?

The short answer is that electricity demand is growing faster than the grid can build new supply. The demand forecast for the 2027/2028 delivery year rose by 5,250 megawatts compared with the prior year’s auction, and PJM confirmed that nearly 5,100 megawatts of that increase is attributable to data center demand. Data centers drove $6.5 billion — 40% — of the $16.4 billion 2027/2028 auction total.

PJM’s independent market monitor attributes $29.4 billion, or 46.2% of all capacity charges across the last four PJM capacity auctions, to data-center load. Those costs are socialized across every ratepayer in the PJM footprint — meaning a family in Freehold is effectively subsidizing the electricity infrastructure needs of AI data centers in Northern Virginia. The market was not designed with this level of concentrated, predictable industrial load in mind.

On the supply side, the problem is equally structural. With electricity demand accelerating and capacity additions facing permitting, financing, and local opposition hurdles, maintaining reliability will depend on faster generation entry, preserving existing resources, and increasing flexibility on the demand side. Utilities have announced plans to retire an additional 15,000 MW of coal generation by 2029, removing dispatchable capacity that has not yet been replaced by an equivalent volume of firm new generation.

Without the temporary price cap negotiated between Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro and PJM in 2024, the auction would have cleared at approximately $530 per megawatt-day, roughly 60% higher. The cap held the ceiling for the 2026/2027 and 2027/2028 auctions, but it does not solve the underlying imbalance — it just limits how sharply the pain can accelerate in any single year.

How does a wholesale auction in Pennsylvania translate to a higher electric bill in Monmouth County?

The mechanism is a layered one, but each step is traceable. PJM runs its capacity auction roughly three years ahead of the delivery year. Capacity costs from each auction flow into bills starting June 1 of the delivery year — so the $329.17 price began hitting bills in June 2026, and the $333.44 price from the December 2025 auction arrives June 2027.

In New Jersey, the step between PJM’s wholesale price and your monthly bill runs through the annual BGS auction administered by the NJBPU. The BGS auction determines, in part, the cost of electricity for most New Jersey residents and many businesses for a 12-month period starting June 1. Utilities buy supply through that auction, and the capacity component of PJM’s wholesale price is embedded in what they bid. Winning BGS prices increased modestly in 2026 compared with 2025, largely due to higher wholesale energy costs and capacity prices in PJM Interconnection.

The 2025 BGS auction — the one that reflected the first large capacity price spike — was where Monmouth County homeowners felt the sharpest jolt. The NJBPU projected average monthly residential bill increases starting June 1, 2025 of 17.24% for PSE&G and 20.20% for JCP&L. JCP&L is the primary utility serving Monmouth County. On June 1, 2026, JCP&L bills moved up another $2.23 per month at the 650 kWh baseline, per the Board of Public Utilities.

Capacity charges make up roughly 15% to 20% of a typical residential bill, and they are set by PJM’s regional auction — not by Trenton. The NJBPU can review a utility’s distribution rate case or approve a solar incentive program, but the capacity component is set regionally. That is precisely what makes this difficult for any individual state regulator, or any individual homeowner, to control unilaterally.

Why does the 6,600 MW gap signal continued upward pressure on New Jersey electric bills beyond May 2026?

A capacity shortfall does not mean the lights go out tomorrow. The shortfall means PJM would enter the delivery year with slimmer reserves and greater operating risk, though it does not necessarily indicate the grid will be unable to meet electricity demand. PJM cited mitigating factors and said it could pursue a backstop reliability procurement to narrow the gap before June 2027.

What the gap does signal is that the structural forces driving prices upward have not been resolved. Cumulative capacity costs to ratepayers through 2033 could reach $100 billion to $163 billion depending on whether the cap mechanism is extended, according to analysis from the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. PJM’s own estimate is that the auction adds approximately $70 per month to the average PJM family’s electricity bill by 2028.

The subsequent capacity auction — for the 2028/2029 delivery year — also cleared below PJM’s reliability requirement. That auction produced a shortfall of 6,831 MW, marking the second consecutive capacity auction in which the entire PJM territory failed to procure enough supply to satisfy the one-day-in-10-years reliability standard. “These auction results show that demand for electricity continues to grow faster than electricity supply,” said PJM President and CEO David Mills.

PJM capacity prices cleared at the cap three years running, raising bills each June through 2028. For a New Jersey homeowner, the upshot is that the 2025 rate increase was not an aberration — it was the opening act of a multi-year re-pricing of grid capacity that will continue to work its way into annual BGS auction results and, from there, into monthly utility bills.

What does a tighter, more expensive grid actually mean for grid reliability in New Jersey?

Beyond the cost question, a grid that consistently fails to procure enough committed capacity is a grid that operates with thinner margins on its worst days. PJM’s reliability standard is designed to ensure grid stability for a one-event-in-10-years scenario. Missing that target does not guarantee outages, but it does mean the buffer between normal demand and an emergency is narrower than it should be.

New Jersey homeowners in Monmouth County have already experienced what an overstressed grid looks like in practice. A December 2025 windstorm knocked out power to tens of thousands of homes across the county. As Green Sun has previously covered on this blog, a December 2025 windstorm knocked out power to more than 48,000 New Jersey homes — a reminder that the physical grid is vulnerable to weather events regardless of what any auction says.

Capacity shortfalls and weather vulnerability compound each other. A grid with a 14.8% installed reserve margin, against a target closer to 20%, has less headroom to absorb an unexpected spike in demand or an unplanned plant outage. The more the grid is stretched, the more a severe weather event — a summer heat dome, a nor’easter, a prolonged cold snap — has the potential to tip a region from “stressed” to “unserved.” New Jersey sits in a part of the PJM footprint where summer peak demand, driven by air conditioning, and winter peak demand, driven by electric heating, both create vulnerabilities.

It is also worth noting that the capacity auction price cap in effect for the 2026/2027 and 2027/2028 auction years has saved New Jersey residential customers roughly $130 per customer per year, or $440 million statewide per year. That cap was a temporary measure negotiated under political pressure. Whether it continues beyond 2029/2030 — and what happens to prices if it does not — is an open question that NJ homeowners cannot individually answer.

How does a natural-gas or propane standby generator insulate a homeowner from grid volatility?

A standby generator does not lower your electric bill; it addresses a different problem. When the grid goes down — whether because of a storm, a strained reserve margin, or a cascading fault — a standby generator keeps your household running independently of whatever is happening on the utility’s side of the meter. Green Sun Energy Services installs Generac home standby generators throughout Monmouth County, sizing the system to the home’s essential or whole-house loads.

A Generac standby generator is operated by natural gas or liquid propane and is designed to supply backup power immediately when it is disrupted, eliminating the setup process typically required by portable generators. The transfer switch detects a utility outage and starts the generator automatically, usually within seconds. Natural gas connects directly to the home’s utility line through a dedicated gas line, so there is nothing to refill or store; liquid propane is the standard option for homes without a gas service.

The fuel supply is what distinguishes a standby generator from other backup options. Natural gas and propane are delivered through pipelines and tanks that operate on separate infrastructure from the electric grid. When a nor’easter takes down power lines across Monmouth County, the gas main is typically unaffected. With natural gas, a Generac can run uninterrupted as long as the gas supply remains uninterrupted; with propane, the system runs consistently as long as there is enough fuel on hand. For comparison with battery-based systems, Green Sun has also published a detailed look at solar plus battery versus generator options for New Jersey homeowners.

All Generac home standby generators include a 5-year limited warranty, per Generac’s published product specifications. The warranty coverage runs comprehensively for years one and two, covers parts in year three, and covers the engine short block and alternator for years four and five, per Generac’s official warranty document. Regular annual maintenance is essential to keeping a standby generator ready when it is needed; Green Sun has covered this in detail in a separate post on why annual Generac maintenance matters for New Jersey homeowners.

Are there other steps a New Jersey homeowner can take to manage energy costs and grid exposure?

A standby generator addresses the reliability side of the equation. For the cost side, the most effective tool available to a New Jersey homeowner is rooftop solar. By generating electricity at the point of use, solar offsets the volume of utility-priced kilowatt-hours a household consumes, which means the capacity charges embedded in those rates have less surface area to work on. Green Sun Energy Services installs residential solar panels throughout Monmouth County and can model the offset for a specific home’s consumption profile.

Solar and a standby generator are not mutually exclusive — in fact, they are complementary. Solar reduces what you buy from the grid on sunny days; a generator keeps you running when the grid is unavailable at night or during extended cloudy periods after a major storm. For homeowners who want to explore both simultaneously, Green Sun’s completed projects are documented on the featured clients page, which includes examples of homes where both systems have been installed.

Beyond generation, understanding New Jersey’s regulatory landscape helps homeowners plan. The NJBPU has pushed for reforms at PJM and negotiated the temporary price cap that moderated the last two auction results. New Jersey and its fellow states argued that customers were being asked to overpay for capacity, and by capping how high those prices could go, the collar helped keep New Jersey’s BGS auction prices lower than they otherwise would have been. Whether that cap extends beyond its current term is a matter for FERC and PJM stakeholders — not something any individual homeowner controls. What homeowners can control is whether their household is prepared for the outages and cost increases that a structurally constrained grid tends to produce. For information on New Jersey’s generator installation requirements under the current electrical code, see Green Sun’s post on New Jersey’s 2023 NEC and what it means for a generator install.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the result of PJM's December 2025 capacity auction?

PJM’s 2027/2028 Base Residual Auction, held December 17, 2025, cleared at the FERC-approved price cap of $333.44 per megawatt-day and secured 134,479 MW of unforced capacity — but fell 6,623 MW short of PJM’s reliability requirement, the first miss in the capacity market’s history. The total cleared value came to approximately $16.4 billion. The delivery year runs from June 1, 2027 through May 31, 2028, so those costs begin flowing into utility bills on June 1, 2027.

Will PJM's capacity auction results raise my New Jersey electric bill in 2027?

Yes, but the size of the increase depends on how the annual New Jersey BGS auction reflects the new wholesale capacity costs. The December 2025 auction cleared at $333.44 per megawatt-day — essentially flat from the prior year’s cap price — which means bills are more likely to see continued pressure rather than a sudden new spike. The 2025 BGS auction already pushed JCP&L bills up 20.2% and PSE&G bills up 17.24%; the 2027 adjustment will depend on the February 2027 BGS auction results certified by the NJBPU.

Why is the PJM capacity price so high?

The primary driver is a surge in electricity demand from AI data centers, which PJM’s independent market monitor attributes to roughly 40% of the December 2025 auction’s $16.4 billion total. At the same time, new generation is not being built fast enough — the December 2025 auction cleared only 774 MW of truly new capacity. Older dispatchable plants are retiring, and the permitting and construction timelines for new plants are measured in years, not months.

What does the 6,623 MW reliability shortfall mean for the risk of power outages in New Jersey?

The shortfall means PJM enters the 2027/2028 delivery year with an installed reserve margin of 14.8% against a target closer to 20% — a thinner buffer between normal demand and an emergency. It does not guarantee outages, but it means the grid has less headroom to absorb an unexpected spike in demand or an unplanned plant failure. PJM can pursue supplemental “backstop” procurement to narrow the gap before June 2027, and it has signaled that it plans to do so.

Does a Generac standby generator lower my electric bill?

No. A standby generator produces electricity from natural gas or propane when the utility grid is unavailable, but it does not reduce what you pay the utility when the grid is running normally. If lowering your ongoing electric costs is the goal, rooftop solar — which offsets the volume of utility-priced electricity you consume — is the more direct tool. Many Monmouth County homeowners pursue both: solar to reduce costs during normal grid operation and a standby generator to maintain function when the grid is unavailable.

How long can a Generac home standby generator run on natural gas?

A Generac connected to a natural gas utility line can run continuously as long as the gas supply remains uninterrupted, subject to a recommended shutdown and inspection at regular intervals per Generac’s guidelines. Propane-powered models typically run three to ten days depending on tank size and the load being carried. Because natural gas infrastructure is physically separate from the electric grid, it is generally unaffected by the same weather events that knock out power lines.

What NJ utility zones does the PJM capacity auction affect?

All four of New Jersey’s electric distribution utilities — JCP&L, PSE&G, Atlantic City Electric, and Rockland Electric — procure supply through the annual NJ BGS auction, and all of them are exposed to PJM’s wholesale capacity prices. JCP&L serves most of Monmouth County. The capacity price set in PJM’s auction flows into the supply portion of your bill each June 1 when the new BGS rates take effect.

Are there any zoning or permitting considerations for installing a standby generator in New Jersey?

Yes. Standby generator installations in New Jersey are subject to local zoning ordinances, the 2023 National Electrical Code as adopted by the state, and in some cases municipal setback requirements. Green Sun has covered this in detail — see the posts on New Jersey’s 2023 NEC requirements for generator installs and on NJ Assembly Bill A4405, which could remove certain zoning hurdles. A licensed installer familiar with local requirements can navigate these before work begins.

The Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

PJM’s December 2025 capacity auction produced two findings that every New Jersey homeowner should understand. First, prices hit the FERC-approved ceiling of $333.44 per megawatt-day for the second consecutive year, locking in another layer of wholesale capacity costs that will begin flowing into New Jersey electric bills on June 1, 2027. Second, and more consequentially, the auction fell 6,623 MW short of PJM’s own reliability target — the first time that has happened in the market’s history. That gap is not a rounding error; it reflects a structural imbalance between surging electricity demand, driven largely by data centers, and a supply side that cannot build new generation fast enough to keep pace. The subsequent auction, for the 2028/2029 delivery year, produced a gap of 6,831 MW, confirming the trend. These are forces operating at the regional grid level, beyond the reach of any individual state regulator or any individual household.

What individual households can control is their own preparedness. A natural-gas or propane standby generator does not reduce your electric bill, but it insulates your home from the most direct consequence of a tighter, more stressed grid: outages. Combined with rooftop solar — which reduces the volume of utility-priced electricity your household consumes on days the grid is running normally — a whole-home energy strategy can address both the cost side and the reliability side of the equation. Green Sun Energy Services installs Generac standby generators and residential solar panels throughout Monmouth County. If you want to understand what a specific system would look like for your home, reach out to the Green Sun team for an assessment.

Sources & Additional Information

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top